Re: Turing test

[Thomas Rolle <c6roth@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Martin Mueller wrote:

> Here is a little puzzle for you all:
> a game record between a person and a computer program. Now which is which,
> and why? Please try to form an opinion by looking only at the moves played,
> even if you happen to know the game already. If you were the human playing
> or if you were writing the program, what would you do differently?
>

I would say that black is the computer. I never played against a program that
played
moves like 2 and 4 in the opening.
I would like to play 19 at f3 instead of f4 and I believe that the computer
(if black is a program) played 19 in answer to 4 and not in answer to 18.
The one space jump is one the shapes wich are played very often by black.

On the other hand the josekis played by white I had often seen played by
Goliath and there is a feeling that White starts to play endgame moves in
the middlegame.

Martin, tell us which of the both players was the computer (in some days). I
think Black
but I don't want to say this absolutly.

Thomas