I know how big nonsense has been performed in the parallel search world. A professor hyatt who has been clearly caught by making up his own speedups. He just has written down a speedup and then calculated from that the search times he needed. This is easily visible. See his frauded data in journal of ICGA (1997). Just complete lies from deep blue team about the speedup as they extrapolated speedup of a few processors to 480. Zugzwang team doesn't take into account the search times, but only shows how many nodes they needed at their bigtime slowed down program. Cilkchess doesn't show any speedup but clearly first slowed down their program 40 times with 'cilk' from MiT, in order to show a better speedup. Chrilly measures an inefficient single cpu search with n processors at a statistical insignificant way. How much more nonsense will we keep seeing in the search world? Here is example of measuring diep world champs 2004 at 4 processors versus 1. Attached also the positions at which was measured. 213 in total.
Attachment:
speedups.xls
Description: Binary data
r2q1rk1/pp1nbppp/4bn2/2pp2B1/3P4/2NBP3/PPQ1NPPP/R3K2R w KQ - ; move 10 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 r2q1rk1/pp2bppp/4bn2/2np2B1/8/2NBP3/PPQ1NPPP/R3K2R w KQ - ; move 11 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 r2q1rk1/pp2bppp/4bn2/3p2B1/8/2NnP3/PPQ1NPPP/R4RK1 w - - ; move 12 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 r4rk1/pp2bppp/4bn2/q2p2B1/8/2NQP3/PP2NPPP/R4RK1 w - - ; move 13 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 2r2rk1/pp2bppp/4bn2/q2p2B1/8/2NQP3/PP2NPPP/R1R3K1 w - - ; move 14 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 5rk1/pp2bppp/4bn2/q2p2B1/2rN4/2NQP3/PP3PPP/R1R3K1 w - - ; move 15 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 5rk1/pp2bppp/4bn2/q1rp2B1/3N4/1PNQP3/P4PPP/R1R3K1 w - - ; move 16 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 5rk1/pp2bppp/1q2bn2/2rp2B1/3N4/PPNQP3/5PPP/R1R3K1 w - - ; move 17 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 2r2rk1/pp2bppp/1q2bn2/3p2B1/3N4/PPNQP3/2R2PPP/R5K1 w - - ; move 18 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 2rq1rk1/pp2bppp/4bn2/3p2B1/1P1N4/P1NQP3/2R2PPP/R5K1 w - - ; move 19 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 2rq1r1k/pp2bppp/4bn2/3p2B1/1P1N4/P1NQP3/2R2PPP/2R3K1 w - - ; move 20 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 3q1r1k/pp2bppp/4bn2/1N1p2B1/1P1N4/P2QP3/2r2PPP/2R3K1 w - - ; move 21 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 3q1r1k/pp1bbppp/5n2/1N1p2B1/1P1N4/P3P3/2Q2PPP/2R3K1 w - - ; move 22 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 3q1r1k/1pQbbppp/p4n2/1N1p2B1/1P1N4/P3P3/5PPP/2R3K1 w - - ; move 23 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 3q1r1k/N1Qbbppp/pp3n2/3p2B1/1P1N4/P3P3/5PPP/2R3K1 w - - ; move 24 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 3qr2k/NQ1bbppp/pp3n2/3p2B1/1P1N4/P3P3/5PPP/2R3K1 w - - ; move 25 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 3qr2k/NQ1bbppp/1p3n2/p2p4/1P1N1B2/P3P3/5PPP/2R3K1 w - - ; move 26 ; WCCC2004 diep - le fous fous a1a1 r3kb1r/3n1ppp/3pb3/q3p1P1/pp2PP2/4B1P1/PPPQ4/R1N1KB1R b KQkq - ; move 16 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 r3kb1r/3n1p1p/3pb1p1/q3p1P1/pp2PP2/3NB1P1/PPPQ4/R3KB1R b KQkq - ; move 17 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 r3kb1r/3n1p1p/3pb1p1/q3p1P1/1p2PP2/pP1NB1P1/P1PQ4/R3KB1R b KQkq - ; move 18 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 r3kb1r/3n1p1p/3pb1p1/q5P1/1p2PP2/pP1NB3/P1PQ4/R3KB1R b KQkq - ; move 19 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 r3k2r/3n1pbp/3pb1p1/q5P1/1p2PP2/pP1NB3/P1PQ4/2KR1B1R b kq - ; move 20 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 r3k2r/3n1p1p/3pb1p1/q5P1/1p2PP2/pPbNB3/P1P2Q2/2KR1B1R b kq - ; move 21 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 2r1k2r/3n1p1p/3pb1p1/q5P1/1p1BPP2/pPbN4/P1P2Q2/2KR1B1R b k - ; move 22 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 2r2rk1/3n1p1p/3pb1p1/q5P1/1p2PP2/pPBN4/P1P2Q2/2KR1B1R b - - ; move 23 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 5rk1/3n1p1p/3pb1p1/q5P1/1p1QPP2/pPrN4/P1P5/2KR1B1R b - - ; move 24 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 1r4k1/3n1p1p/3Qb1p1/q5P1/1p2PP2/pPrN4/P1P5/2KR1B1R b - - ; move 25 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 2r3k1/3n1p1p/3Qb1p1/q5P1/1p2PP2/pPrN4/P1P4R/2KR1B2 b - - ; move 26 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 2r3k1/3n1p1p/3Q2p1/q5P1/1p2PPb1/pPrN4/P1P4R/2K1RB2 b - - ; move 27 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 2r3k1/5p1p/3Q2p1/q1n1N1P1/1p2PPb1/pPr5/P1P4R/2K1RB2 b - - ; move 28 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 2r3k1/5p1p/3Qb1p1/q1n1N1P1/1p2PP2/pPr5/P1P4R/1K2RB2 b - - ; move 29 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 2r3k1/5p1p/3Qb1p1/q1n1N1P1/1p2PP2/pP2R3/P1P4R/1K3B2 b - - ; move 30 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 3r2k1/5p1p/4b1p1/q1n1N1P1/1p2PP2/pP2R3/P1PQ3R/1K3B2 b - - ; move 31 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 6k1/5p1p/4b1p1/q1n1N1P1/1p2PP2/pP2R3/P1PR4/1K3B2 b - - ; move 32 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 6k1/2q2p1p/4b1p1/2n1N1P1/1p2PP2/pP2R3/P1PR2B1/1K6 b - - ; move 33 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 6k1/2q2p2/4b1pP/2n1N3/1p2PP2/pP2R3/P1PR2B1/1K6 b - - ; move 34 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 6k1/2q2p2/4b2P/2n1N1p1/1p2PP2/pP4R1/P1PR2B1/1K6 b - - ; move 35 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 6k1/2q5/4bpNP/2n3p1/1p2PP2/pP4R1/P1PR2B1/1K6 b - - ; move 36 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 5N2/2q4k/4bp1P/2n3p1/1p2PP2/pP4R1/P1PR2B1/1K6 b - - ; move 37 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 5N1k/2q5/4bp1P/2n3p1/1pP1PP2/pP4R1/P2R2B1/1K6 b - - ; move 38 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 5N1k/2q2b2/5p1P/2n1P1p1/1pP2P2/pP4R1/P2R2B1/1K6 b - - ; move 39 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 5N1k/4qb2/5p1P/2n1P1P1/1pP5/pP4R1/P2R2B1/1K6 b - - ; move 40 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 5N1k/4qb2/4P2P/2n3p1/1pP5/pP4R1/P2R2B1/1K6 b - - ; move 41 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 7k/4qb2/4N2P/6p1/1pP5/pP4R1/P2R2B1/1K6 b - - ; move 42 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 7k/4q3/4N1bP/6p1/1pP5/pP4R1/P2R2B1/2K5 b - - ; move 43 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 3R3k/8/4q1bP/6p1/1pP5/pP4R1/P5B1/2K5 b - - ; move 44 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 3R4/7k/4q1bP/6p1/1pP5/pP4R1/P2K2B1/8 b - - ; move 45 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 3R4/7k/6bP/5qp1/1pP5/pP2R3/P2K2B1/8 b - - ; move 46 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 3R4/7k/6bP/5q2/1pP3p1/pP2R3/P3K1B1/8 b - - ; move 47 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 3R4/7k/6bP/5q2/1pP5/pP2RBp1/P3K3/8 b - - ; move 48 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 8/7k/6bP/8/1pP5/pP2RBp1/P2RK3/1q6 b - - ; move 49 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 8/7k/6bP/8/1pP1B3/pP2R1p1/P2RK3/6q1 b - - ; move 50 ; WCCC2004 falcon - diep a1a1 r3k2r/pppqb1pp/1n2b3/8/1P1PpN2/2N1B3/1P3PPP/R2QK2R w KQkq - ; move 15 ; WCC2004 diep - junior a1a1 r3k2r/ppp1b1pp/1n2q3/8/1P1Pp3/2N1B3/1P3PPP/R2QK2R w KQkq - ; move 16 ; WCC2004 diep - junior a1a1 r3k2r/ppp1b1pp/1n4q1/3P4/1P2p3/2N1B3/1P3PPP/R2QK2R w KQkq - ; move 17 ; WCC2004 diep - junior a1a1 r4rk1/ppp1b1pp/1n4q1/3P4/1P2p3/2N1B3/1P3PPP/R2Q1RK1 w - - ; move 18 ; WCC2004 diep - junior a1a1 4rrk1/ppp1b1pp/1n4q1/2BP4/1P2p3/2N5/1P3PPP/R2Q1RK1 w - - ; move 19 ; WCC2004 diep - junior a1a1 4rrk1/Rpp1b1pp/6q1/2BP4/1Pn1p3/2N5/1P3PPP/3Q1RK1 w - - ; move 20 ; WCC2004 diep - junior a1a1 4rrk1/Rpp3pp/6q1/2bP4/1Pn1p3/2N5/1P2QPPP/5RK1 w - - ; move 21 ; WCC2004 diep - junior a1a1 4rrk1/Rpp3pp/6q1/2PPn3/4p3/2N5/1P2QPPP/5RK1 w - - ; move 22 ; WCC2004 diep - junior a1a1 2rqk2r/1p2b1pp/p1bppn2/6B1/4P3/2NQ4/PPP3PP/1K1R1B1R b k - ; move 13 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2rq1rk1/1p2b1pp/p1bppn2/6B1/4P3/2N4Q/PPP3PP/1K1R1B1R b - - ; move 14 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2rq1rk1/1p1bb1pp/p2ppn2/4P1B1/8/2N4Q/PPP3PP/1K1R1B1R b - - ; move 15 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2rq1rk1/1p1bb1pp/p3pn2/4p1B1/8/2NB3Q/PPP3PP/1K1R3R b - - ; move 16 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2rq1rk1/1p1bb1p1/p3pn1p/4p3/8/2NB3Q/PPPB2PP/1K1R3R b - - ; move 17 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2r2rk1/1p1bb1p1/pq2pn1p/4p3/8/2NB3Q/PPPB2PP/K2R3R b - - ; move 18 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2r2rk1/1p1b2p1/pq2pn1p/2b1p3/4N3/3B3Q/PPPB2PP/K2R3R b - - ; move 19 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2r2rk1/1p1b2p1/pq2p2p/2b1p3/4B3/7Q/PPPB2PP/K2R3R b - - ; move 20 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2r3k1/1p1b2p1/pq2pr1p/2b1p1B1/4B3/7Q/PPP3PP/K2R3R b - - ; move 21 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2r3k1/1p1b2p1/pq2pr1p/4p1B1/3bB3/2P4Q/PP4PP/K2R3R b - - ; move 22 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2r3k1/1p1b2pQ/pq2pr2/4p1p1/3bB3/2P5/PP4PP/K2R3R b - - ; move 23 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2r2k2/1p1b2pQ/pq2pr2/4p1p1/3PB3/8/PP4PP/K2R3R b - - ; move 24 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2r2k2/1p1b2pQ/pq2pr2/6p1/3pB3/8/PP4PP/K2R1R2 b - - ; move 25 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2r1bk2/1p4pQ/pq2prB1/6p1/3p4/8/PP4PP/K2R1R2 b - - ; move 26 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2r2k1Q/1p4p1/pq2prb1/6p1/3p4/8/PP4PP/K2R1R2 b - - ; move 27 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2Q5/1p2k1p1/pq2prb1/6p1/3p4/8/PP4PP/K2R1R2 b - - ; move 28 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 4b3/1p2k1p1/pq2pr2/6p1/3p4/8/PPQ3PP/K2R1R2 b - - ; move 29 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p2k1p1/pq2pr2/1b4p1/3p4/8/PPQ3PP/K2RR3 b - - ; move 30 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p2k1p1/pq2pr2/1b4p1/8/2Qp4/PP4PP/K2RR3 b - - ; move 31 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p3kp1/pq2pr2/1b4p1/6P1/2Qp4/PP5P/K2RR3 b - - ; move 32 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p3kp1/pq2p3/1b4p1/P5P1/2Qp4/1P3r1P/K2RR3 b - - ; move 33 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p3kp1/pq2p3/6p1/b5P1/2QR4/1P3r1P/K3R3 b - - ; move 34 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p3kp1/pq2p3/1b4p1/6P1/2Q2R2/1P3r1P/K3R3 b - - ; move 35 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p3kp1/pq2p3/1b4p1/6P1/5Q2/1P5P/K3R3 b - - ; move 36 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p4p1/pq2p3/1b4p1/6P1/5Q2/1P5P/1K2R3 b - - ; move 37 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p4p1/p2qp3/1b4p1/6P1/5Q2/1P5P/1K1R4 b - - ; move 38 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p2q1p1/p3p3/1b4p1/6P1/1Q6/1P5P/1K1R4 b - - ; move 39 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p2q1p1/p3p3/6p1/3R2P1/1Q6/1P2b2P/1K6 b - - ; move 40 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p2q1p1/p3p3/1b4p1/3R2P1/4Q3/1P5P/1K6 b - - ; move 41 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p2q1p1/p1b1p3/6p1/6P1/4Q3/1P1R3P/1K6 b - - ; move 42 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p2q1p1/p1b5/4p1p1/6P1/4Q3/1P1R3P/2K5 b - - ; move 43 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p4p1/p1b1q3/4p1p1/6P1/1P2Q3/3R3P/2K5 b - - ; move 44 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p2q1p1/p1b5/4p1p1/6P1/1P2Q3/1K1R3P/8 b - - ; move 45 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p2q1p1/p1b5/6p1/4p1P1/1P2Q3/1K3R1P/8 b - - ; move 46 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 6k1/1p4p1/p1bq4/6p1/4p1P1/1P2Q2P/1K3R2/8 b - - ; move 47 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p4pk/p1bq4/5Rp1/4p1P1/1P2Q2P/1K6/8 b - - ; move 48 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p4pk/p1b5/5Rp1/4p1P1/1PK1Q2P/7q/8 b - - ; move 49 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1pq3pk/p1b5/6R1/4p1P1/1PK1Q2P/8/8 b - - ; move 50 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1pq3pk/p7/3b2R1/4p1P1/1P2Q2P/1K6/8 b - - ; move 51 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p4pk/p7/3b2R1/4p1P1/1P2Q2P/7q/1K6 b - - ; move 52 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p4pk/p7/3b2R1/4p1P1/1P5P/8/1KQ4q b - - ; move 53 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p4pk/p7/3b2R1/4p1P1/1P5P/8/2K5 b - - ; move 54 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p4pk/p7/4R3/4p1P1/1b5P/8/2K5 b - - ; move 55 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p4p1/p5k1/4R3/4p1P1/1b5P/1K6/8 b - - ; move 56 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p4p1/p5k1/8/b3R1P1/7P/1K6/8 b - - ; move 57 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p4p1/p1b3k1/4R3/6P1/7P/1K6/8 b - - ; move 58 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 8/1p4p1/p1b2k2/5R2/6P1/7P/1K6/8 b - - ; move 59 ; WCC2004 shredder - diep a1a1 2rq1rk1/pp1bppbp/2n3p1/2p5/2BPP3/2P1B3/P3NPPP/2RQ1RK1 w - - ; move 12 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 2rq1rk1/pp1bppbp/6p1/n1p5/2BPP3/2P1BP2/P3N1PP/2RQ1RK1 w - - ; move 13 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 2r1qrk1/pp1bppbp/6p1/n1p5/3PP3/2PBBP2/P3N1PP/2RQ1RK1 w - - ; move 14 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 2rq1rk1/pp1bppbp/6p1/n1p5/3PP3/2PBBP2/P2QN1PP/2R2RK1 w - - ; move 15 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 2rq1rk1/pp2ppbp/6p1/n1p5/b2PP3/2PBBP2/P2QN1PP/1R3RK1 w - - ; move 16 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 2r2rk1/pp1qppbp/6p1/n1P5/b3P3/2PBBP2/P2QN1PP/1R3RK1 w - - ; move 17 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 2rr2k1/pp1qppbp/6p1/n1P5/b3PP2/2PBB3/P2QN1PP/1R3RK1 w - - ; move 18 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 2rr2k1/pp1q1pbp/4p1p1/n1P5/b2BPP2/2PB4/P2QN1PP/1R3RK1 w - - ; move 19 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 2rr2k1/pp1q1p1p/4p1p1/n1P5/b2bPP2/2PB1R2/P2QN1PP/1R4K1 w - - ; move 20 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 2rr2k1/pp1q1p1p/2n1p1p1/2P5/b2PPP2/3B1R2/P2QN1PP/1R4K1 w - - ; move 21 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 2rr2k1/pp1q1p1p/2n3p1/2Pp4/b3PP2/3B1R2/P2QN1PP/1R4K1 w - - ; move 22 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/pprq1p1p/2n3p1/2PpP3/b4P2/3B1R2/P2QN1PP/1R4K1 w - - ; move 23 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/ppr1qp1p/2n3p1/2PpP3/b4P2/3B3R/P2QN1PP/1R4K1 w - - ; move 24 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/1pr1qp1p/p1n3p1/2PpP3/b4P2/2QB3R/P3N1PP/1R4K1 w - - ; move 25 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/npr1qp1p/p5p1/2PpP3/b4P2/2QB3R/P3NKPP/1R6 w - - ; move 26 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/nprbqp1p/p5p1/2PpP3/1Q3P2/3B3R/P3NKPP/1R6 w - - ; move 27 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/npr1qp1p/p5p1/1bPpP3/1Q3P2/3B2R1/P3NKPP/1R6 w - - ; move 28 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/1pr1qp1p/p5p1/1nPpP3/1Q3P2/6R1/P3NKPP/1R6 w - - ; move 29 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/npr1qp1p/p5p1/2PpP3/PQ3P2/6R1/4NKPP/1R6 w - - ; move 30 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/1pr1qp1p/pQn3p1/2PpP3/P4P2/6R1/4NKPP/1R6 w - - ; move 31 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/1p1rqp1p/pQn3p1/2PpP3/P4P2/3R4/4NKPP/1R6 w - - ; move 32 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r2k1/1p1rqp1p/pQn3p1/2P1P3/P2p1P2/3R2P1/4NK1P/1R6 w - - ; move 33 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r3k/1p1rqp1p/pQn3p1/2P1P3/P2p1P1P/3R2P1/4NK2/1R6 w - - ; move 34 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r3k/1p1rq2p/pQn2pp1/2P1P3/P2p1P1P/3R2P1/5K2/1R4N1 w - - ; move 35 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r3k/1p1r3p/pQn2qp1/2P5/P2p1P1P/3R2P1/5K2/1R4N1 w - - ; move 36 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r3k/1p1r1q1p/pQn3p1/2P5/P2p1P1P/3R2P1/5K2/4R1N1 w - - ; move 37 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 3r3k/1p1r3p/pQn3p1/2P2q2/P2p1P1P/3R1NP1/5K2/4R3 w - - ; move 38 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 5r1k/1p1r3p/pQn3p1/2P2q2/P2p1P1P/5NP1/3R1K2/4R3 w - - ; move 39 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 5r1k/1p1r4/pQn3pp/2P2qN1/P2p1P1P/6P1/3R1K2/4R3 w - - ; move 40 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 7k/1p1r1r2/pQn1N1pp/2P2q2/P2p1P1P/6P1/3R1K2/4R3 w - - ; move 41 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 7k/1p1rr3/p1n1N1pp/2P2q2/P2p1P1P/1Q4P1/3R1K2/4R3 w - - ; move 42 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 7k/1p1rrq2/p1n1N1pp/2P5/P1Qp1P1P/6P1/3R1K2/4R3 w - - ; move 43 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 4r2k/1p1r1q2/p1n1N1pp/2P5/P1Qp1P1P/6P1/3R2K1/4R3 w - - ; move 44 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 4r2k/1p1r1q2/p1n1N2p/2P4p/P1Qp1P2/6P1/3R2K1/4R3 w - - ; move 45 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 4r2k/1p1r1q2/p1n1N2p/2P5/P1Qp1P1p/6P1/5RK1/4R3 w - - ; move 46 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 6rk/1p1r1q2/p1n1N2p/2P5/P1Qp1PPp/8/5RK1/4R3 w - - ; move 47 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 6rk/1p1r1q2/p1n1N2p/2P5/P4PPp/3p4/4QRK1/4R3 w - - ; move 48 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 6rk/1p1r4/p1n1N1qp/2P5/P4PPp/3p4/5RK1/3QR3 w - - ; move 49 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 6rk/1p1r4/p1n1N2p/2P5/P4Pqp/3p4/5R1K/3QR3 w - - ; move 50 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 7k/1p1r4/p1n1N2p/2P5/P4Prp/3p4/5R1K/4R3 w - - ; move 51 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 7k/1p1r4/p1n1N2p/2P5/P4P1p/3p2r1/3R3K/4R3 w - - ; move 52 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 6k1/1p1r4/p1n1N2p/2P5/P3RP1p/3p2r1/3R3K/8 w - - ; move 53 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 8/1p1r1k2/p1n1N2p/2P2P2/P3R2p/3p2r1/3R3K/8 w - - ; move 54 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 8/1p1r1k2/p1n1N2p/2P2P2/P6R/3p1r2/3R3K/8 w - - ; move 55 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 8/1p1r1k2/p1n1N2R/2P2r2/P7/3p4/3R3K/8 w - - ; move 56 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 8/1p1rk3/p1n1N2R/2P2r2/P7/3p4/6RK/8 w - - ; move 57 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 8/1p1rkrR1/p1n1N2R/2P5/P7/3p4/7K/8 w - - ; move 58 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 8/1p1r1k2/p1n1N2R/2P5/P7/3p4/7K/8 w - - ; move 59 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 6k1/1p1r4/p1n4R/2P3N1/P7/3p4/7K/8 w - - ; move 60 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 6k1/1p6/p1n4R/2P5/P2rN3/3p4/7K/8 w - - ; move 61 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 6k1/1p6/p1n4R/2P5/r7/3p4/3N3K/8 w - - ; move 62 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 6k1/1p6/p1n4R/2P5/3r4/3p2K1/3N4/8 w - - ; move 63 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 8/1p4k1/p1n4R/2P5/3r4/3p1K2/3N4/8 w - - ; move 64 ; WCC2004 diep - jonny a1a1 1rb1kb1r/3n1ppp/pqppp3/6B1/4PP2/1PN2Q2/P1P3PP/1K1R1B1R b k - ; move 12 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 1rb1kb1r/5ppp/pqppp3/2n3B1/4PP2/1PN2Q2/P1P1B1PP/1K1R3R b k - ; move 13 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 1rb1kb1r/2q2ppp/p1ppp3/2n2PB1/4P3/1PN2Q2/P1P1B1PP/1K1R3R b k - ; move 14 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 1rb1kb1r/2q2ppp/p1pp4/2n1pPB1/4P3/1PN2Q2/P1P1B1PP/1K1R1R2 b k - ; move 15 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 1rb1kb1r/2q2ppp/2pp4/p1n1pPB1/4P3/1PN2Q2/P1P1B1PP/K2R1R2 b k - ; move 16 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 1rb1kb1r/2q2ppp/2pp4/2n1pPB1/P3P3/2N2Q2/P1P1B1PP/K2R1R2 b k - ; move 17 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 1rb1kb1r/2q2pp1/2pp3p/2n1pP2/P3P2B/2N2Q2/P1P1B1PP/K2R1R2 b k - ; move 18 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 1rb1kb1r/5pp1/2pp3p/q1n1pP2/P1B1P2B/2N2Q2/P1P3PP/K2R1R2 b k - ; move 19 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 2b1kb1r/5pp1/2pp3p/q1n1pP2/Pr2P2B/1BN2Q2/P1P3PP/K2R1R2 b k - ; move 20 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 4kb1r/5pp1/b1pp3p/q1n1pP2/Pr2P2B/1BN2Q2/P1P3PP/K2RR3 b k - ; move 21 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 4k2r/4Bpp1/b1pp3p/q1n1pP2/Pr2P3/1BN2Q2/P1P3PP/K2RR3 b k - ; move 22 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 7r/4kpp1/b1pp3p/q1n1pP2/Pr2P3/1BN3Q1/P1P3PP/K2RR3 b - - ; move 23 ; WCC2004 movei - diep a1a1 r1bq1rk1/ppp1bpp1/2n2n1p/3p2B1/3P4/P1N1P3/1PQ2PPP/R3KBNR w KQ - ; move 9 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 r2q1rk1/ppp1bpp1/2n1bn1p/3p4/3P3B/P1N1P3/1PQ2PPP/R3KBNR w KQ - ; move 10 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 r2q1rk1/pppnbpp1/2n1b2p/3p4/3P3B/P1NBP3/1PQ2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - ; move 11 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 r4rk1/pppnqpp1/2n1b2p/3p4/3P4/P1NBP3/1PQ2PPP/R3K1NR w KQ - ; move 12 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 r4rk1/ppp1qpp1/1nn1b2p/3p4/3P4/P1NBP3/1PQ1NPPP/R3K2R w KQ - ; move 13 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2r2rk1/ppp1qpp1/1nn1b2p/3p4/3P1N2/P1NBP3/1PQ2PPP/R3K2R w KQ - ; move 14 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2r2rk1/ppp2pp1/1nn1b2p/3p2q1/3P1N2/P1NBP3/1PQ2PPP/R4RK1 w - - ; move 15 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2r2rk1/ppp2pp1/1nn4p/3p2q1/3P1Nb1/P1NBP1P1/1PQ2P1P/R4RK1 w - - ; move 16 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2r2rk1/pppb1pp1/1nn4p/3p2q1/3P1N2/P1NBP1PP/1PQ2P2/R4RK1 w - - ; move 17 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2rq1rk1/pppb1pp1/1nn4p/3p4/3P1N1P/P1NBP1P1/1PQ2P2/R4RK1 w - - ; move 18 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2rq1rk1/ppp2pp1/1nn4p/3p4/1P1P1NbP/P1NBP1P1/2Q2P2/R4RK1 w - - ; move 19 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2rq1rk1/ppp2pp1/2n4p/3p4/nP1P1NbP/P2BP1P1/2Q2P2/R4RK1 w - - ; move 20 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2rq1rk1/ppp2p2/2n4p/3p2p1/QP1P1NbP/P2BP1P1/5P2/R4RK1 w - - ; move 21 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2rq1rk1/1pp2p2/p1n4p/3p2p1/QP1P2bP/P2BP1P1/5PN1/R4RK1 w - - ; move 22 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2r2rk1/1pp2p2/p1n2q1p/3p2p1/1P1P2bP/P2BP1P1/2Q2PN1/R4RK1 w - - ; move 23 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2rr2k1/1pp2p2/p1n2q1p/3p2p1/1P1P2bP/P2BP1P1/2Q2PN1/R1R3K1 w - - ; move 24 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2rr2k1/1pp2p2/2n2q1p/1p1p2p1/3P2bP/P2BP1P1/2Q2PN1/R1R3K1 w - - ; move 25 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2r3k1/1pp2p2/2nr1q1p/1pQp2p1/3P2bP/P2BP1P1/5PN1/R1R3K1 w - - ; move 26 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2r3k1/2p2p2/1pnr1q1p/1Q1p2p1/3P2bP/P2BP1P1/5PN1/R1R3K1 w - - ; move 27 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2rn2k1/2p2p2/1p1r1q1p/1Q1p2p1/3P2bP/P2BP1P1/R4PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 28 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2r3k1/2p2p2/1pnr1q1p/1Q1p2p1/P2P2bP/3BP1P1/R4PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 29 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 2r3k1/2pb1p2/1pnr1q1p/1Q1p2p1/P2P3P/3BP1P1/2R2PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 30 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 4r1k1/2pb1p2/1pnr1q1p/3p2p1/P2P3P/3BP1P1/1QR2PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 31 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 6k1/2pb1p2/1pnrrq1p/3p2p1/P2P3P/2RBP1P1/1Q3PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 32 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 6k1/2pb1p2/1pnrr2p/1B1p1qp1/P2P3P/2R1P1P1/1Q3PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 33 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 6k1/2pb1p2/1pnrrq1p/3p2p1/P2P3P/2RBP1P1/1Q3PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 34 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 6k1/2pbqp2/1pnrr2p/3p2p1/P2P3P/2RBP1P1/5PN1/1QR3K1 w - - ; move 35 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 6k1/2pbqp2/1p1rr2p/3p2p1/Pn1P3P/2RBP1P1/2Q2PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 36 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 7k/2pbqp1B/1p1rr2p/3p2p1/Pn1P3P/2R1P1P1/2Q2PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 37 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 7k/2pbqp1B/1pnrr2p/3p2p1/P2P3P/2R1P1P1/1Q3PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 38 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 7k/2pbqp2/1pnr1r1p/3p2p1/P2P3P/2R1P1P1/1Q3PN1/1BR3K1 w - - ; move 39 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 7k/2pb1p2/1pnrqr1p/3p2p1/P2P3P/2R1P1P1/3Q1PN1/1BR3K1 w - - ; move 40 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 7k/2pb1p2/1pnrq1rp/3p2p1/P2P3P/2RQP1P1/5PN1/1BR3K1 w - - ; move 41 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 7k/2pb1pr1/1pnrq2p/3p2p1/P2P3P/2R1P1P1/5PN1/1BRQ2K1 w - - ; move 42 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 6k1/2pb1pr1/1pnrq2p/3p2p1/P2P3P/2R1PQP1/5PN1/1BR3K1 w - - ; move 43 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 6k1/2pb1pr1/1p1rq2p/3p2p1/Pn1P3P/2RBPQP1/5PN1/2R3K1 w - - ; move 44 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 6k1/2pb1pr1/1pnrq2p/3p2p1/P2P3P/2R1PQP1/5PN1/1BR3K1 w - - ; move 45 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 6k1/2pb1pr1/1pnrq3/3p2p1/P2P4/2R1PQP1/5PN1/1BR3K1 w - - ; move 46 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 6k1/2pb1pr1/1pnrq3/3p4/P2P2p1/2R1PQP1/5P2/1BR1N1K1 w - - ; move 47 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 4q1k1/2pb1pr1/1pnr4/3p4/P2P2p1/2R1P1P1/5PQ1/1BR1N1K1 w - - ; move 48 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1 4q1k1/2pb2r1/1pnr4/3p1p2/P2P2p1/2R1P1P1/5P2/1BR1N1KQ w - - ; move 49 ; WCCC2004 diep - crafty a1a1
_______________________________________________ computer-go mailing list computer-go@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx http://www.computer-go.org/mailman/listinfo/computer-go/